Pandemic-Born Cohort Shows Persistent Gaps in Math and Reading
The first second graders born during the pandemic era are now navigating their early school years with surprisingly persistent gaps in core subjects. A fresh analysis from the education researcher network NWEA indicates that this cohort trails pre pandemic peers in math and reading, even as some math gains have appeared year after year.
The findings, drawn from assessments administered during the 2024-25 school year, underscore that the disruption of early childhood during lockdowns extends beyond the classroom. The pattern appears to reflect systemic factors both inside schools and in the surrounding economy, not a single missed step.
Experts emphasize that the first second graders born during the pandemic era face a multi front challenge. While math scores show marginal improvement since the height of the crisis, reading progress remains stalled for many students, suggesting a fragile rebound after years of interrupted instruction and pandemic-related stressors.
Key Data Points for the Pandemic-Born Cohort
- On average, students in the pandemic-born group of first and second graders scored about 6 to 8 points below pre pandemic cohorts in 2024-25, with growth from year to year only modestly narrowing the gap.
- Reading performance shows little to no net recovery, hovering roughly 3 to 5 points behind baseline across the same age group.
- Math has edged upward in 2024-25, yet the gains do not fully close the gap to pre pandemic levels, while reading remains flatter overall.
- The analysis covers roughly 2.4 million students in the 2024-25 year, spanning urban, suburban and rural districts with varying levels of poverty.
- Districts with higher poverty rates show larger gaps in both math and reading for the pandemic-born cohort, signaling widening inequities if unaddressed.
Why Parents and Policymakers Should Pay Attention
The outcomes for the first second graders born during the pandemic era matter beyond test scores. Reading and math proficiency in early grades correlate with long-term educational attainment, higher earnings and stronger workforce readiness. When early gaps persist, families face higher out-of-pocket costs for tutoring, and school districts confront steeper needs for targeted supports and resources.
Families already feel the pinch. A growing share has leaned on tutoring, early literacy programs and after school options to keep pace, often dipping into family budgets and retirement savings to cover costs. The immediate financial pressure combines with the risk that a generation could miss the foundation needed for college readiness and steady career trajectories.
In interviews with researchers and education policy analysts, there is a shared view that the pattern seen in the pandemic-born first and second graders is not about a single failed strategy. Instead, it reflects a complex mix of interrupted early learning, varying access to high-quality instruction, differing levels of family support at home, and broader economic stress that affects both learning environments and students’ well-being.
Financial Implications for Families and the Economy
- Parents report higher out-of-pocket costs for tutoring and supplemental programs, with average monthly tutoring expenditures rising by an estimated 15 to 25 percent for households with students in the pandemic-born cohort.
- Some families divert funds from retirement and college savings to cover academic support, potentially altering long-term financial plans and loan burdens.
- If the math and reading gaps persist into later grades, studies suggest a potential drag on lifetime earnings for this cohort compared with peers who did not experience early pandemic disruption.
- Federal and state funding aimed at catch-up programs has grown since 2021, but effectiveness varies by district; resource allocation and targeted tutoring remain central questions for lawmakers.
- Expand high-dosage tutoring specifically in early literacy and foundational math skills for the pandemic-born cohort.
- Invest in early-reading interventions, phonics-based programs and small-group instruction that align with students’ pace of learning.
- Offer extended-day options and summer programs to prevent summer learning loss and strengthen the school-year gains in math and reading.
- Provide family outreach and supports to help parents engage with learning at home, including take-home resources and coaching on home-based practice.
For the first second graders born during the pandemic era, the path to closing gaps remains a public finance and education policy priority. The latest data remind policymakers that early childhood disruptions have lasting economic consequences, not just test-score quirks. As schools and communities implement targeted supports, the hope is that this cohort will begin to catch up in both math and reading and, in time, help stabilize family budgets and the broader labor market.
Bottom Line
The pandemic born cohort of first and second graders is still not fully out of the woods. The most recent NWEA findings show the first second graders born during the crisis continue to lag in math and reading, with reading showing minimal recovery and math only gradually closing the gap. The implications extend to households and the economy, making continued investment in targeted early supports essential for both student success and future economic growth.
Discussion